JUSTICE FOR ROBERT DARBY
WHAT ABDUL AHMED SAYS HE DID & DIDN'T SEE
HE SAW
* Black BMW drive past him, pull up and stop in middle of road, to the right of where he was standing by the pub. It was pointing towards Gants Hill station.
* "Small silver car, like a Ford Fiesta."
* Parked cars on the side of the road where he was walking/standing (but didn't recognise any of them as *****'s silver BMW 6 Series convertible with its black roof).
* Darby get out of driver's side (far side to where he was standing) first, looking aggressive and holding a yellow 'scraper' (Stanley knife).
* Heard shouting and use of the F-word by the two drivers.
* The 2 drivers "confront" each other or "clash" by the black car.
(***** admitted that he and Darby had physical contact but Moore did not touch the victim)
* The passenger in the silver car, the taller man wearing a dark blue jacket, get out of silver car holding a kitchen knife with a 6-inch blade wrapped/rolled up in white cloth, move around the BACK of the silver car, then approach and stab Darby with an upward motion on the left side of his chest.
* The driver of the silver car standing next to the passenger who did the stabbing.
* Darby "walk" (not run) towards the pub and then stagger before collapsing near entrance to pub car park.
HE DIDN'T SEE
* Jason Moore, or anyone else resembling his height of 6ft 5ins.
* *****'s Silver BMW approaching or parked outside house No.25 in Perth Road.
* Any passengers in the black BMW (which supports our theory that Hunt got out of that car).
* Whether Darby left his driver's door open.
* Darby strike ***** with a 'scraper'/Stanley knife, causing ***** to stumble or fall.
* Driver of silver car holding a knife, stab or hit Darby.
* Hands of the silver car driver, because his view was obscured by black car.
* Jason briefly pursue Darby after the stabbing.
* Where the two men in the silver car went after the incident.
* The make and model of *****'s silver car (BMW 630i N52 Convertible with black roof).
* Paul Hunt drive the black BMW into car park, take knife out of Darby's hand and hide it behind advertising board.
* Whether Sally Palmer arrived in her small silver Renault Modus before or after the incident.
* Didn't know what colour car Sally Palmer was driving.
​
Front and rear views of the Renault Modus car identical to that driven by witness Sally Palmer, which pulled up behind Darby's black BMW before moving very slowly around it. We strongly believe this is the "small silver car" Abdul Ahmed referred to, the one he thought he saw ***** and Hunt emerge from.
This is the actual silver BMW 6 Series Convertible that ***** drove to the crime scene. As you can see, it is significantly different in both size and shape to the Modus. But Ahmed has never mentioned seeing a car fitting the description of *****'s vehicle. Which, in turn, means he didn't see Jason Moore get out of it.